Book Review: Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir
Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
Introduction:
Project Hail Mary is a high-concept science fiction novel with enormous stakes and an ambitious premise. While I admired the originality and scale of the story, I found myself disengaged at times due to pacing issues and an overreliance on detailed math and science explanations that slowed the narrative for me. I have not had much experience with Sci Fi. Dune was the last big one I remember reading and I loved it. I also have read Atmosphere by Taylor Jenkins Reid which had some similar plot points. I was hoping this would align closer to that. I have not read the Martian, so I wasn’t familiar with Weir’s writing style either. This was a book club selection. It got me to read a book I otherwise would have left at the bookstore so that is a positive.
Quick Facts
- Release: May 2021
- Read: January 2026
- Reading Time: Moderate to long
- Pages: 476
- Format Recommendation:
Audiobook may work better for some readers due to the conversational tone, but the physical format allows easier skimming of dense scientific explanations. My book club recommends the audiobook. They claim that it’s a great reader who keeps the pace going more smoothly. I think I would need that if I ever read this book again. The physical book left my ADHD begging to read anything else in some sections. - Perfect for:
Fans of hard sci-fi, science-heavy problem solving, and high-stakes space missions
Genre and Writing Style:
This novel is firmly rooted in hard science fiction. Andy Weir’s writing style is logical, analytical, and highly detailed, often pausing the story to walk the reader step-by-step through scientific concepts and calculations. While this precision will be a strength for some readers, it frequently disrupted pacing and emotional momentum for me.
- Spice Level: 🌶️ (none)
- Trigger Level: 💀💀 (moderate)
Summary: A Brief Overview (Without Major Spoilers)
From Goodreads:
Ryland Grace is the sole survivor on a desperate, last-chance mission — and if he fails, humanity and Earth itself will perish. Stranded light-years from home with no memory of how he got there, Grace must solve an impossible scientific mystery in order to save everything he knows. As his memories return, he discovers the true nature of his mission and the unimaginable stakes tied to its success.
What Worked for Me:
- The concept is compelling and genuinely high stakes. I mean I personally would have been freaking out if I woke up in space and had no clue how I got there. Grace was surprisingly calm. But the idea that the sun is going to get covered enough to kill Earth and one man is out to save us all. It’s unique.
- Ryland Grace– I mean other than flashbacks he was one of only two main characters. But I liked him. He was solution oriented and quirky. I think part of the charm was that I already know Ryan Gosling is going to play him in a film (love the initials matching) and so I thought of him the whole time. That did help me enjoy this book more.
- Rocky– I picture Wall- E. The way he talks, I just picture that. He seemed sweet and weird and friendly and I just liked him. It? Whatever you want to call him, Rocky was cool.
- The Ending– Without giving away spoilers it was a very American ending. I liked it after spending the whole book wondering if he was going to meet a tragic fate.
What Didn’t Work for Me: Trigger Warnings and Criticisms
- The pacing lagged during long scientific explanations: There was a lot of vocab. My coworkers from book club who listened to the audio book didn’t have an issue. The math teacher who recommended the book for the club, loved it. I… struggled with all the scientific mumbo jumbo. Not that I couldn’t follow it, but that it bored the ever-loving crap out of me.
- The nonlinear format: We get information in the form of flashbacks. Ryland doesn’t remember anything, even his name, when he wakes up. Weir uses an excessive number of flashbacks to fill in the plot points. We as the reader almost know more than Grace when the book starts. I honestly wish they had had a part one that was the plot of the flashbacks being just the regular plot and the part two was the plot up in space.
Trigger Warnings / Content Notes:
- Isolation
- High-stress survival scenarios
- Existential threat to humanity
Final Thoughts:
Project Hail Mary is a book I can respect without fully loving. Its ambition and scientific rigor are impressive, but the dense technical explanations kept me emotionally distant and slowed my reading experience. A solid 3-star read that will absolutely resonate with the right audience — even if it wasn’t the right fit for me.
📚 Study Guide
Tips for Readers:
- Consider the audiobook if technical explanations feel overwhelming
- Don’t be afraid to skim dense scientific passages
- Best suited for readers who prioritize concept over character
Discussion Questions:
- How did the scientific detail affect your engagement with the story?
- Did the pacing improve or worsen as the novel progressed?
- Which moments felt most emotionally impactful, and why?
- What balance should hard sci-fi strike between realism and readability?
ReadRantRepeat 
Leave a comment